Ryder Cup 2021: Back-to-back gimme controversies show problems with golf's unwritten rule

By Joel Beall  

Andrew Redington

HAVEN, Wis.—A 90-second sequence Saturday morning produced bruised egos and indignant stares and affronts to manhood, and while it generated some savory social media clips, it was no surprise. Like poor fashion choices and awkward celebrations, this sort of matter is ingrained in the Ryder Cup.
This sort of matter being, obviously, gimme putts.

The nature of match play—where scoring happens on a hole-by-hole basis rather than the cumulative total—means balls do not need to find the bottom of the cup to count. Holes can be and are often conceded when the opponents know they cannot answer. And that is well and good and a sign of sportsmanship, the very ideal this event was built upon.

The issue is when holes that should be conceded are not. Or maybe the issue lies with the very idea that a hole is expected to be conceded. The same vessel for sportsmanship is often used for gamesmanship, with others contending there’s no connotation involved and it’s strictly competition.

On Saturday morning at Whistling Straits this tornado of trouble touched down twice. The first involved Patrick Cantlay and Xander Schaufeele and Lee Westwood on the sixth hole. Westwood and partner Matt Fitzpatrick were 1 up through five holes, with Fizpatrick facing a 15-footer to push the advantage to 2. Fitzpatrick missed, but didn’t leave much meat on the bone, nothing more than 18 inches. It is a distance well inside the “friendship circle,” a distance that usually motions an opponent to lift his thumb up to move to the next hole. No such gesture was given by the Americans. Now, Westwood and his short game is a fraught relationship, yet even for a shaky putter, it is a putt most would assume to be given. In the Americans' defense, they were down in the match at that juncture. Westwood was incredulous at going through the exercise, but cleaned up what was left to remain 1 up.

Then, barely a minute later, cameras caught Justin Thomas—who was 2 down through seven with Jordan Spieth—tapping in a two-footer and proceeding to lay his putter horizontal in the direction of Bernd Wiesberger and Viktor Hovland, indicating the putt was “inside the leather” and should have been conceded.

Gimme etiquette would side with Thomas, not just due to the length but because he was down in the match. Conversely, with the Europeans getting manhandled through three sessions, every putt and every point weighed heavy, and Thomas had unleashed a primal yell the hole before when cutting the deficit to 2 that may have gotten under the Euros’ skin.

Thomas and Jordan Spieth ultimately won over Hovland and Wiesberger 2 up, while Westwood and Fitzpatrick lost 2 and 1. None of the players spoke of the incidents afterwards, although no comments were needed to understand how each part felt. The flames had barely died when Shane Lowry made the same gesture as Thomas on the first hole of his afternoon match when having to putt out a shortie.

So who is in the right and wrong? The inherent problem with unwritten rules is that, well, they are unwritten. Every language of golf has gimme in its lexicon but it lacks a universal definition. It is an ambiguity that acts as an agent of chaos and controversy.

The prevailing response to those upset at having to make a gimme is, “Well, if it’s a gimme, it shouldn’t be hard to make it.” It’s a sentiment that’s true but fails to understand the heart of the problem. Gimme grievance isn’t the possibility of a miss; it’s that having to make a stroke is a sign of disrespect. That the player is so short on temerity that the gimme is no gimme at all. A golfer, no matter the skill level, is a prideful beast, and this undercuts the very current he or she rides.

Maybe the only way to eliminate the problem is to eliminate gimmes, period. Make everyone putt everything out. If that seems harsh, we give you the case of the “Concession,” where Jack Nicklaus gave Tony Jacklin a two-footer to end he 1969 Ryder Cup in a tie. History has viewed the moment as one of goodwill, and this year the Ryder Cup will bestow the Nicklaus-Jacklin Award to one player from each team that embodies the spirit of the event.

But it was a moment that was not viewed in such light when it happened, with many of Nicklaus’ teammates and captain Sam Snead furious at the Golden Bear. They had retained the cup, but a Jacklin miss would have given the U.S. a win. "When it happened, all the boys thought it was ridiculous to give him that putt," Snead would later say. "We went over there to win, not to be good ol' boys."

Proving that, when it comes to gimmes, no answer is ever the right answer.


Ryder Cup 2021: All 24 golfers playing at Whistling Straits, ranked

Ryder Cup 2021: Raymie Burns talks Ryder Cup pairings - will we see McIlroy and Lowry together?

Ryder Cup 2021: Harrington to follow Bjorn and get a tattoo if Europe win the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: The European Team pulled an absolutely brilliant move to get the U.S. fans on their side

Ryder Cup 2021: 5 holes that could prove pivotal in winning or losing at Whistling Straits

Ryder Cup 2021: Ian Poulter says the U.S. fans have been wishing him well this week. Wait, what?

Ryder Cup 2021: Team Europe bonds by making fun of Rory McIlroy's tiny hat for his tiny head

Ryder Cup 2021: Lee Westwood has a hilariously simple reason for why he's been so good in the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: Photo Gallery: Wednesday’s Preview Day at Whistling Straits

Ryder Cup 2021: Lowry feels he deserves place on team as he looks to join Irish Ryder Cup legends

Ryder Cup 2021: Ian Poulter explains why he's so damn good at the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: How practice rounds are (possibly) telegraphing United States pairings

Ryder Cup 2021: Why Europe will win the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: Why America will win the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: How analytics have become a crucial factor in the outcome of the matches

Ryder Cup 2021: 8 all-time pairings we wish we could have seen

Ryder Cup 2021:Harrington’s Experienced Europeans looking to prove age is just a number against youthful USA side

Ryder Cup 2021: Seve Ballesteros made a beautiful gesture to stoke Sergio Garcia's love of playing for Europe

Ryder Cup 2021: Jordan Spieth says Steve Stricker is the most prepared captain he's seen

Ryder Cup 2021: Why this controversial rule will be in effect should a player test COVID positive

Ryder Cup 2021: Captain Padraig Harrington reminds his players fewer have competed in matches than gone to space

Ryder Cup 2021: Why Rory McIlroy needs this Ryder Cup as much as it needs him

Ryder Cup 2021: Bryson speaks! Says hands are fine, teases 'something fun' coming with Brooks

McIlroy reminded by Harrington how special it is to play in the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup:2021: Lowry feels his form would have warranted a Ryder Cup pick ‘no matter who was captain’

Ryder Cup 2021: The 15 most inconsequential moments in Ryder Cup history

Ryder Cup 2021: Ranking the definitive moments in all 18 modern Ryder Cups

Ryder Cup 2021: Harrington v's Stricker

Ryder Cup 2021: Whistling Straits is a home away from home for the Europeans

Ryder Cup 2021: Steve Stricker is 'not worried about Brooks' … no matter what the question

Ryder Cup 2021: Bryson DeChambeau wants to end feud with Brooks Koepka, according to his coach

Ryder Cup 2021: Why players were warned of not breaking this rule at Whistling Straits

Ryder Cup 2021: Everything European captain Padraig Harrington must know to spank the Yanks

Ryder Cup 2021: Everything American captain Steve Stricker must know to whip the Euros

Ryder Cup 2021: LOVE HATE: Team bonding at the Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: With eyes on Bryson-Brooks feud, how much does team chemistry matter?

Ryder Cup 2021: Ranking Team Europe's players by how well their names fit into that sweet Fleetwood/Molinari song

Ryder Cup 2021: The big edge Steve Stricker has as home captain that is often overlooked

Ryder Cup 2021: Love or loathe him, Ian Poulter is always Europe's man to beat

Ryder Cup 2021: The original Mr. Ryder Cup

Ryder Cup 2021: Lowry to realise ‘career-long dream’ as he is set for Ryder Cup debut

Join over 61,000 Irish golfers and get golf's biggest stories first every day


Other news